I once saw a guy where he had at least 3-4 piercings including under skin body mods all just on his dick, could barely see the thing haha! and they were also very thick as well. I used my king size condom (as he was girthy and big anyway) and it was no problem.
Whenever I worry about condoms I always think back to images where someone has put their entire leg in one without it breaking and think to myself 'its probably going to be fine'

As long as there is lube, the condom is in date, put on properly, I think you'll always be good to go.
Right length width-wise so its comfortable helps too. The guys I have seen when I knew I would need a king size for it to go on properly even if they are not big length-wise and their face lights up lol, the same guys that say 'condoms are so uncomfortable it hurts' are literally cutting off dick circulation half the time with regular condoms and thats why they don't like them too

Either way a regular condom will usually still work on girthier guys but because of the width I think there may be more of a chance of it breaking too so its not worth the risk.